71 Banyan Dr, Hilo, Hawaii, 96720, United States
resort comparison guide

Hilo Hawaiian vs Volcano Forest Inn

Choosing between Hilo Hawaiian Hotel and Volcano Forest Inn? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, amenities, policies & more so you can decide which stay is the best fit for your next Hawaii getaway.

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel resort
Hilo Hawaiian Hotel
All-Ages • Oceanfront Hilo • Full-Service Hotel

Best for travelers who want a full-service, oceanfront Hilo base on Banyan Drive with hotel amenities, on-site dining, a pool, and easy access to Hilo-area sights.

Volcano Forest Inn resort
Volcano Forest Inn
Rainforest Inn • Volcano Area • Quiet Stay

Better for travelers who want a quieter rainforest inn experience near Volcano, with a more tucked-away, nature-focused stay than a traditional hotel.

Quick Verdict: Hilo Hawaiian Hotel vs Volcano Forest Inn

If you want a classic Hilo hotel stay with an oceanfront setting, restaurant and lounge options, a freshwater pool, fitness center, and all-ages appeal, Hilo Hawaiian Hotel is the stronger pick.

If your priority is a peaceful rainforest setting near Volcano rather than being in Hilo town, Volcano Forest Inn is the better fit for a slower, more nature-immersed stay.

Bottom line: choose Hilo Hawaiian Hotel for convenience, services, and a Hilo waterfront base; choose Volcano Forest Inn for a quieter inn-style stay closer to the Volcano area.

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel vs Volcano Forest Inn – At a Glance

Category Hilo Hawaiian Hotel Volcano Forest Inn
Overall Vibe Full-service, all-ages oceanfront hotel on Banyan Drive with a traditional resort feel, dining, pool, and Hilo convenience. Quiet rainforest inn with a more secluded, nature-forward atmosphere near Volcano rather than a larger hotel setting.
Location On Banyan Drive in Hilo, close to Liliʻuokalani Gardens, Coconut Island, and Hilo-area beaches and town attractions. In the Volcano area, better suited to travelers who want to stay near rainforest surroundings and the Volcano side of the island.
Rooms & Suites Hotel-style rooms and amenities suited to couples, families, and general travelers who want a familiar full-service base. Inn-style lodging with a quieter, more personal feel for travelers who prefer a less commercial stay.
Dining On-site dining includes a steakhouse-style restaurant and Waiʻoli Lounge, with breakfast, dinner, shared plates, drinks, and live music noted. Better for guests who are comfortable with a smaller inn experience and planning meals around the Volcano area.
Pools & Beach One outdoor oceanside freshwater pool with sundeck; the hotel is oceanfront, though the adjacent lava-rock beach is not recommended for swimming. Rainforest setting rather than a pool-and-beach hotel scene, with the appeal centered on quiet surroundings instead of resort-style water amenities.
Kids & Family Children of all ages are welcome, and kids 17 and under can stay free using existing bedding within room occupancy limits. More appropriate for low-key travelers and families who prefer a quiet inn environment over a full-service hotel atmosphere.
Price & Value Best value for travelers who will use hotel amenities like parking, WiFi, fitness center access, pool towels, and on-site dining. Best value for travelers who prioritize rainforest quiet and Volcano-area positioning over a larger amenity list.

Rooms & Suites: Full-Service Hotel Comfort vs Rainforest Inn Quiet

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel – Room Style

Rooms at Hilo Hawaiian Hotel suit travelers who want a straightforward hotel base with the convenience of on-site services, dining, and resort-style amenities.

  • All-ages hotel setting suitable for couples, families, and general travelers
  • High-speed internet access is advertised in guest rooms by the hotel booking engine
  • Resort fee includes perks such as WiFi, parking subject to availability, water bottles, and fitness center use

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel is the better pick if you want a familiar hotel setup with more services on property and a convenient Hilo waterfront location.

Volcano Forest Inn – Room Style

Volcano Forest Inn offers a more intimate inn-style experience, with the stay centered on rainforest surroundings rather than a full-service hotel footprint.

  • Quieter lodging style for travelers who prefer a nature-focused base
  • Better fit for guests planning time around the Volcano area
  • Best for travelers who do not need a broad list of resort amenities

If you want a more secluded, rainforest-oriented stay and do not need the services of a larger hotel, Volcano Forest Inn is the better match.

Dining & Drinks: On-Site Hotel Venues vs Smaller Inn Simplicity

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel – Restaurants & Bars

Dining is a clear advantage at Hilo Hawaiian Hotel, with on-property venues that make it easy to have breakfast, dinner, drinks, or a relaxed lounge stop without leaving the hotel.

Expect:

  • A steakhouse-style restaurant serving breakfast and dinner
  • WaiÊ»oli Lounge with shared plates, a full bar, ocean views, and live music noted on weekdays
  • Keiki menu availability during iCafe and Lounge service periods

Volcano Forest Inn – Restaurants & Bars

Volcano Forest Inn is better approached as an inn stay, where dining is less about a full hotel restaurant lineup and more about planning around the Volcano area.

  • More low-key dining expectations than a full-service hotel
  • Best for travelers who do not require multiple on-site venues
  • Works well if the priority is the rainforest setting rather than hotel dining variety

If on-site dining and lounge convenience matter most, Hilo Hawaiian Hotel has the stronger food-and-drink setup.

Pools & Beach: Oceanside Hilo Hotel vs Rainforest Volcano Stay

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel – Pool & Beach Scene

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel has one outdoor oceanside freshwater pool with a sundeck, giving guests a classic hotel pool option in an oceanfront setting.

  • Outdoor freshwater swimming pool with sundeck
  • Pool and sun deck are listed as open daily from morning to early evening
  • Oceanfront location, though the adjacent lava-rock beach is not recommended for swimming

Volcano Forest Inn – Pool & Beach Scene

Volcano Forest Inn is not the choice for a resort-style pool or beach scene; its appeal is the quieter rainforest environment near Volcano.

  • Nature-focused setting instead of a hotel pool complex
  • Better for guests who want calm surroundings over beach access
  • Best for travelers using the inn as a peaceful Volcano-area base

If you want a pool, oceanfront atmosphere, and Hilo waterfront convenience, Hilo Hawaiian Hotel is the better fit.

Kids & Family: All-Ages Hotel Convenience vs Quiet Inn Atmosphere

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel – Family Fit

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel is an all-ages property where children are welcome, making it the more practical choice for families who want standard hotel services and amenities.

  • Children of all ages are welcome
  • Children 17 and under can stay free using existing bedding within maximum occupancy limits
  • On-site dining, pool access, and Hilo location add convenience for family trips

Volcano Forest Inn – Family Fit

Volcano Forest Inn can work for travelers who want a quiet, low-key base, but it is less about family-oriented hotel amenities and more about a peaceful inn setting.

  • Better for families comfortable with a smaller lodging environment
  • Good fit for travelers prioritizing quiet over on-site facilities
  • Less resort-like than Hilo Hawaiian Hotel

If your family wants more convenience, dining, and pool access on property, Hilo Hawaiian Hotel is the stronger choice.

Price & Value: Which Big Island Stay Feels More Worth It?

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel – Value Snapshot

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel offers the most value when you want a full-service Hilo base with included-fee amenities and easy access to town, beaches, and nearby sights.

  • Best for travelers who will use the pool, fitness center, parking, and WiFi
  • Great if you want on-site dining and lounge options
  • Strong value for an all-ages Hilo stay with traditional hotel conveniences

Volcano Forest Inn – Value Snapshot

Volcano Forest Inn is the better value if your priority is a quieter rainforest atmosphere near Volcano rather than a Hilo hotel with a broader amenity list.

  • Best for travelers who want a peaceful Volcano-area base
  • Stronger for guests who prefer small-scale lodging
  • Worth it if nature and quiet matter more than pool, lounge, and full-service hotel features

Who Wins? Best Big Island Stay by Travel Style

Best for Hilo Convenience
Hilo Hawaiian Hotel resort

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel

Choose Hilo Hawaiian Hotel if you want a full-service, all-ages hotel in Hilo with an oceanfront setting, pool, dining, lounge, and convenient town access.

Best for Rainforest Quiet
Volcano Forest Inn resort

Volcano Forest Inn

Volcano Forest Inn is the better pick if you want a quieter rainforest inn experience near Volcano and are less focused on hotel-style amenities.

Best for Pool & On-Site Dining
Hilo Hawaiian Hotel resort

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel

For travelers who want the ease of on-site restaurants, a pool, fitness center, and a Banyan Drive location near Hilo sights, Hilo Hawaiian Hotel is the safer choice.

Best for Volcano-Area Base
Volcano Forest Inn resort

Volcano Forest Inn

If you want a more tucked-away stay with a nature-first feel and closer positioning to the Volcano area, Volcano Forest Inn is the better match.

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Hilo Hawaiian Hotel

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Close